EA Sports Madden NFL 25 could have been a timeless sports gaming entry alongside NBA 2K11 and FIFA 13 if it had been released in 2018. However, it feels like a missed opportunity with layers of unnecessary content that distract from the game itself. As someone who hasn’t played a Madden game seriously since 2017, diving into Madden NFL 25 with an early access code from EA Sports was a refreshing experience. The clean interface, energizing soundtrack, depth of the franchise mode, and balanced gameplay all showcase how far the series has come.
The gameplay in Madden NFL 25 is a refined experience, emphasizing the cerebral and methodical pace of the pro game. EA Orlando has perfected their use of the Frostbite engine, with new solo tackle animations, dynamic ball interactions, and revamped blocking mechanics. The pass protection menu now offers more nuanced protection schemes, enhancing the overall experience. However, some glitchy interactions with the new “Boom Tech” feature could use some patching.
The commentary in Madden NFL 25 lacks the depth and emotion that could elevate the game to the next level, missing the casual, conversational tone that brings life to the commentary. While the gameplay is fantastic, it lacks some intangible soul that could make it truly special.
Superstar mode in Madden NFL 25 offers an immersive experience, starting with the NFL Draft Combine mini-games that shape your player’s draft stock. However, the mode’s pacing can become repetitive, with random cutscenes disrupting the flow between games. The AI in this mode can be perplexing, leading to bizarre outcomes that break immersion.
In the franchise mode of Madden NFL 25, the draft presentation has been overhauled with a new big board and details on each player drafted. Scouting remains largely unchanged from Madden 24, with slow sequences that can be glitchy when skipped. While Madden NFL 25 brings visual updates to the draft process, the scouting mechanics may disappoint some players.