Have you ever experienced the challenge of running on six different treadmills in one day? Or perhaps you’ve had the opportunity to work out on seven diverse rowing machines (outside of a CrossFit class)? My personal favorite task involves lugging multiple boxes of adjustable dumbbells up the stairs of my three-story walk-up. This is all part of my role as the main fitness writer at CNET. It’s a demanding job, but it must be done. I collaborate with our expert editors to enhance our testing approach for fitness equipment. We’ve honed our methodology for evaluating these machines to provide you with more insight on why certain products earn our seal of approval.
As a consumer of these products myself, I understand that individuals searching for a treadmill may prioritize factors such as the machine’s dimensions and durability, along with a suitable speed range for running or walking. On the other hand, those in the market for an elliptical might focus on resistance options and stride length. While fitness equipment may vary in functionality, the end goal remains the same: to facilitate a productive workout. It’s crucial to carefully consider whether the fitness equipment you’re eyeing is the right fit for your needs and space.
When it comes to reviewing fitness equipment, we assess various criteria such as features, software, functionality, assembly, and warranty coverage. Our evaluation process involves testing the equipment extensively, ensuring it performs as promised and is user-friendly. We also consider factors like ease of assembly, warranty details, and the availability of white glove delivery services.
We utilize a 1-5 rating system across different subcategories to gauge the performance of each product. By applying an in-house formula, we assign an overall score on a 1-10 scale to determine the standout products in our assessments. Products that score below 6.5 are typically not recommended by our team.
In selecting the fitness equipment we review, we rely on a mix of well-known brands and lesser-known options to provide a diverse range of choices. Our testing process involves requesting products directly from manufacturers, conducting thorough research, and testing a minimum of six machines simultaneously. We prioritize customer reviews and the latest models to guide our selections.
As the fitness equipment tester at CNET, I bring over a decade of experience in wellness and fitness journalism to the table. I’ve tested a wide array of equipment, from treadmills and ellipticals to rowing machines and smart fitness mirrors. I approach testing with a hands-on perspective, aiming to provide valuable insights for our readers.
Our testing facility at the CNET warehouse in Louisville serves as the primary location for evaluating fitness equipment. The space allows us to test larger pieces of equipment and conduct thorough assessments. In some cases, I may test equipment from my own home or explore demos at showrooms.
During the testing process, I dedicate significant time to each machine, ensuring thorough evaluation of its features, performance, and usability. The testing period typically spans about a week, with daily sessions lasting around six hours. I meticulously document my observations and compare the machines to identify strengths and weaknesses.
At CNET, we take pride in our comprehensive and rigorous approach to testing fitness equipment, striving to provide our readers with reliable recommendations and valuable insights for their fitness journeys.